Go to Google Groups Home    sci.geo.geology
Re: Ping Pong Stuart Weinstein

Stuart <bigdak...@aol.com>

On Sep 8, 12:35 am, don findlay <d...@tower.net.au> wrote:

> df wrote:-

> http://tinyurl.com/yu5xtdhttp://tinyurl.com/32zg52
> ---------------------------------------
> Come on Stuart,  My world is falling apart, I thought I knew what
> Plate Tectonics was saying but I didn't know it was like this.  Tell
> me Mr Bercovici is wrong and that the subducting slab is not pulling
> the world apart (because it's cold ) (because it's dense). The slab,
> that is.   Tell me the subducting slab doesn't  really drive Plate
> Tectonics after all.    I always thought the earth being hot inside
> and making convection currents had something to do with it, but now I
> learn, No, ..there is no need for potassium or any other 'um' in the
> core, ..

Sheesh. Such a silly diatribe. Or is it really a plea for help?

Of course heat sources are needed. If the Mantle was not hot, there
wouldn't
be any subduction. Slabs have buoyancy because the mantle is hot.

I explained the basic physics of this mode of convection in posts
to Timberwoof. I suggest you review it.

Once again you've gone off half cocked and made a fool of yourself.

Again.

Stuart