As far as I know, they should be roughly equal.
Reasoning is htat both URLs have the same 'content', so any benefit
for having topical words in the URL/Address (for links and such) is
present in both... I doubt if google pays attention to ?=& etc.
The real benefit appears with UF-URLs (User Friendly) - if they are
correctly constructed, you can make memorable and impressionable URLs
that appeal all in themselves.
I've even seen URLs with 'power phrasing' and 'call to action' terms
in them...
http:// . www . somesite . tld / products / buy-red-shoes-now
http:// . www . somesite . tld / shoes / you-want-these-shoes
I thought it was a stroke of genius (personally I don't have the
stones to try it out myself though.).
Wonder....
If you squished it all up... could it become subliminal?
http:// . www . somesite . tld / ob / one /
thesearenotthedroidsyouarelookingfor
Name the film.
Did it work?